auteurs
Christophe Kuchly et Raphaël Cosmidis

> article précédent

Times New Roman

Times New Roman

How one Agence Transe Presse news inspired a bit too much an article from The Times, a newspaper which now denies any plagiarism.

Partager


Humour is always more successful when the reader is a native speaker, and even more when we talk about a fake news. Subtlety and hints implied, quite easily spotted by a wise reader, get sometimes lost in translation. Knowledge of the media is an important element as well. McLuhan's famous line "The message is the medium" makes all sense here. The Cahiers du Football have no intention to get information out and there is not one journalist who makes calls and uses sources on their behalf. This context, well-known by french readers and journalists, even if some people got caught in the past, is not known abroad.

 



 

A copy a bit too consistent

Ok, let's admit it, true information can follow wrong information. Purely by chance, or as a trigger. A football club falsely linked to a player might get information about him, find him interesting and eventually sign him. Why not. But the case here seems much clearer.
 

First step : the fake news is published here in the night from March 11th to March 12th, with a name ("Dream Football League"), a picture, and figures completely made up by the writer. This has to be clearly understood: Les Cahiers' piece was published before The Times' piece. A simple Google search will prove that.
 

Second step : March 13th, around 3:30 AM, The Times publishes exclusive information weirdly similar. Name of the project, date of launching, number of clubs participating (even on invitation), spending limits, and the same picture. An almost perfect match. Except that everyone in England is yet to realize that.
 

Shortly after the publication of the article, other British papers run the story. Opinion pieces on the topic appear and English-speaking journalists talk with each other on Twitter, saddened by the possibility of such a project. They are quickly warned by the usual Cahiers readers, especially by us, Christophe and Raphaël, who write on les Dé-Managers, a blog associated with Les Cahiers. We tell them that their exclusive is actually based on an entirely fictional article. At that moment, few of them take us seriously.

 

Source or not source

Attacked by strangers in the middle of the night on the reliabilty of their sources, the Times' journalists are asleep or extremely discreet. Their colleagues stand up for them, sure of their probity. After all, the article is written by Oliver Kay, chief football correspondent for The Times. It's true, the man is known to be reliable. But what can reputation do against a body of presumptive evidence so huge? Soon, questions are infinite, and our knowledge of Les Cahiers makes us representatives.
 

While some Times readers are feeling duped and the writer of the opinion piece is wondering whether he has just written about nothing concrete, a stranger, whose profile seems solid, invites Christophe to chat with him via direct messages. The man assures that in this fake news delirium, we hit the truth. The name would be fake (DFL, also used in The Times article) but the idea of sixteen teams going to Doha to play a competition, starting from 2015, would be true. Negotiations with QSI (owner of PSG) would exist, something that three English teams' owners would have confirmed to The Times. The idea would exist backstage and journalists would have been aware of it for a while. Anyway, the speed with which the news was covered shows how the world of football goes crazy with its fantasies whenever Qatar is mentioned.
 

If the explanation can be credible, the fact that a fake scoop would have pushed journalists from The Times to reactivate their sources to give a true scoop, added to the same name and the same figures...this still seems odd. So does the use of the picture, created for the satirical piece, presented by The Times as a picture created by the promoters of the project. It's normal, replies the one who has now introduced himself a one of the sources. He claims to know about Qatari projects. The article would be just a test to bother the UEFA and kill the Financial Fair Play, and using the elements from the Agence Transe Presse fake news would only back up the three-pages story (how would using a fake news help build veracity?) without giving all the elements. Is this source real? Is he just a fraud ? Either way may be possible but we have collected a lot of hints leading us to think this source is a fraud who pretends to have information. So has Richard Whittall from Counter Attack.

 

A lot of questions

Was Oliver Kay really tricked by this man (he happens to follow him on Twitter, which may not mean anything)? Did his source, whoever it is, send him the picture we used in our piece? Did Oliver Kay get real information and somehow it got mixed up with ours, completely made up? There is no way to know the truth yet and we, for the time being, are just allowed to make guesses. But one thing is sure: made-up facts, published on our website in a satirical article with no intention to fool foreign medias, ended in The Times print edition 24 hours later. There would have been something to laugh about had The Times staff not tried to justify themselves by presenting us as profiteers who wanted to make the most of the situation.
 

On the face of things, only The Times will be able to explain what happened, or will have to do so. Oliver Kay used the occasion of a weekly chat on The Times website this Wednesday to announce a forthcoming publication of evidence. We are now waiting, while remaining circumspect when dealing with such methods. The next few days should bring their revelations, small or huge ones. Unless, of course, Les Cahiers du football are hiding a psychic from the world, a bigwig from The Times or someone close to qatari leadership (Qatar FA have denied the genuineness of the project). Last time we checked, we were not.
 

Partager

Les médias et les journalistes


Julien Momont
2016-01-14

Ballon d’Or 2015 : copinage et préférences nationale et continentale ?

Que se cache-t-il derrière les 498 votes du Ballon d’Or 2015? Réponse avec une analyse minutieuse, statistique et beaucoup trop sérieuse.


Christophe Kuchly
2015-11-19

Les footballeurs et le mythe de la vitesse

Si quelqu’un vous explique qu’un joueur peut courir plus vite qu’un sprinteur, c’est sans doute plus par fascination pour la vitesse que sur la base de données fiables. Car les gens les plus rapides, on les trouve sur la piste, et c’est tant mieux.


Gilles Juan
2015-11-17

Le désastre à la télé

Lorsqu'on a perdu quelqu’un de proche, ou le proche d’un proche, un camarade ou un concitoyen ; lorsqu’on a eu peur ; lorsqu’on a souffert de l’atrocité terroriste, on a en outre dû encaisser le traitement médiatique de tout cela.


>> tous les épisodes du thème "Les médias et les journalistes"

Sur le fil

RT @ANDREAnthony22: @cahiersdufoot On en est à 4 défaites de suite en Coupe + 6 en championnat. Donc oui.

Avec tous les tampons sur sa carte de fidélité, l’AS Saint-Étienne a peut-être droit à une victoire contre le PSG, sait-on jamais.

"Bon, comment on fait? Les tirages c’est un peu chiant… - On n’a qu’à faire deux plombes de trucs soporifiques avant. - Génial, on fonce!"

Les Cahiers sur Twitter

Le forum

CDF sound system

aujourd'hui à 03h30 - Rolfes Reus : J'aime bien la formule telle quelle, même s'il y a peut-être un effet fin de liste (je n'ai pas... >>


Jeux d'Olympe

aujourd'hui à 02h57 - Tricky : Ah mais je n'ai pas dit que j'étais en désaccord là-dessus (voir aussi London 2012). Mais... >>


Lost horizons

aujourd'hui à 02h33 - magic_patator : et alors 09/02/2016 à 16h06 Sur la météo au nord, comme je disais je n'y suis pas allé. Mais... >>


Bréviaire

aujourd'hui à 02h31 - Milan de solitude : Rémy sans famine "Loïc Rémy prochaine cible des millions chinois ?" (foot01.com) Ouais, je... >>


Les jaunes, héros zen

aujourd'hui à 02h16 - sansai : Heureusement il y a quand même Jules Iloki qui rappelle que bon, on fait juste un peu moins... >>


Scapulaire conditionné

aujourd'hui à 01h30 - Anglachel : (Quant au poste de Gardien de but des Girondins de Bordeaux les règles sont effectivement floues,... >>


Gerland à la détente

aujourd'hui à 01h09 - T'as Caluire le Cuire : J'avais dit après le match de championnat au Parc que je n'attendais plus rien de cette saison et... >>


Paris est magique

aujourd'hui à 00h59 - Coach Potato : la menace Chantôme Latéral, ton job prioritaire sera d'empêcher ton gars de déborder /... >>


En Vert et contre tout

aujourd'hui à 00h52 - Moravcik dans les prés : Notre série de matches tous les 3-4 jours s'étend donc. Elle a commencé le 31 janvier contre... >>


Observatoire du journalisme sportif

aujourd'hui à 00h36 - Charterhouse11 : France 2 qui invite Samuel Etienne à la mi-temps du match Paris-Lyon pour qu'il nous explique... >>


Les brèves

Mettre les boules de Flipper sur le terrain

"Monaco, dauphin en danger." (lequipe.fr)

Vous ne viendrez plus chez nous par hasard

"Banderoles stéphanoises : ‘Totalement inadmissible’ pour le PSG." (lequipe.fr)

Get back

"Quatre retours à Liverpool." (lequipe.fr)

Abou Diary

"OM : des nouvelles des blessés." (topmercato.com)

Carpi, c'est pas fini !

"Carpi ne se rend pas." (lequipe.fr)